Dhrithi Bangera Dharmendra (PhD Scholar), Dr. Ishrat Munawer (Assistant Professor) ,Dr. Aswathy Gopi (Assistant Professor), SRM University AP
Any attempt made to explore how mental health outcomes differ across various sociodemographics would easily lead to the recognition of the fact that people of LGBTQIA+ identities have high burdens of mental health, more so than their cisgendered heterosexual counterparts. Studies on queer mental health have consistently highlighted the higher incidences of depression, anxiety, and suicidality among queer people. What makes the LGBTQIA+ community so vulnerable to adverse mental health outcomes and what are we doing about it?
Ilan H. Meyer, Distinguished Senior Scholar for Public Policy and Professor affiliated with Columbia University who studies mental health in sexual minorities proposed that sexual minorities experience additional stress apart from the day-to-day stress that people are already vulnerable to experiencing. He terms this excess stress as “minority stress” and traces it to dominant cultures and societal norms that stigmatise minority identities and subject them to prejudice and discrimination. Such stigmatising experiences may further be internalised, as reflected by their constant expectations of rejection and hiding of their identities. This theory, first described in the context of sexual minorities, has since been studied in relation to gender minorities as well.
Consider the overwhelming amount of decisions that any queer person must make explicitly to cope with this stress on an everyday basis:
“Is this a safe place to be in?”
“Can I reveal my identity?”
“Would they reject me if they found out about my identity?”
“What are the places that I am allowed to be in without fearing rejection or harm?”
Although the disciplines of psychology and psychiatry have previously contributed to the dangerous idea that being queer in itself is a mental disorder, there is now an increase in scholarships within these disciplines that highlight how such ideas are rooted in dominant narratives that solely favour monogamous heterosexual relationships within the framework of marriage and that the mental health diagnoses of queer people are a result of the stigmatisation of their identities and experiences. Despite the shift away from the pathologisation of queer identities, mental health treatment and therapy spaces have been actively enforcing and reinforcing cisgendered heteronormative values. This occurs in the form of assumption that intimate spaces are shared in heterosexual contexts and that people perform gender in rigid dominant binaries. For instance, questions related to families still revolve around the dominant, colonial ideas of a “traditional family”, often imagined involving a father, a mother, and children. Such assumed familial relations, prevents claiming found families and imagining alternative forms of intimate relationships.
The actual awareness of queer experiences is limited even amongst psychologists. This is reflected in studies that explore therapy satisfaction amongst queer participants who have sought therapy. These studies highlight that despite having a higher burden of mental health and even having the intent to seek therapy, queer people face barriers in seeking therapy. When they do approach therapists, they might further be faced with the burden of having to explain their identities which results in the delaying of the therapy process. Moreover, despite the removal of homosexuality and gender nonconformity as mental disorders in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) and International Classification of Diseases (ICD) which are the two widely used classification systems to categorise mental disorders, the years of scholarship and discourses produced during the period when queer identities were pathologised have led to dehumanising narratives and practices revolving queer people. In 1992, Kirk and Kutchins wrote that the American Psychiatric Association’s removal of homosexuality as a mental disorder from the DSM in 1973 was more of an act of submission to the pressures from gay rights activists rather than a social conscious reflection of the harms caused by imposing medical categories that manifest as othering of queer people. The lack of measures taken to responsibly mitigate the effects of the damage already caused by the diagnostic categories, the continued cisgendered heteronormative discourses within the disciplines of psychology and psychiatry, and the treatment of queer-affirmative training in therapy as optional have together created a psychotherapeutic environment wherein a queer person seeking therapy may not be guaranteed a therapist who is queer-affirmative or even informed about queer identities.
The ambiguities and ignorance in therapeutic and academic spaces is further fueled by psychology’s long history of attempting to avoid political conversations and regarding dominant, colonial sociocultural narratives as objective truths. In the context of queer mental health, this is manifested in research studies that study stigma and discrimination against queer people in isolation, refusing to take into consideration the sociopolitical contexts that produce such discriminatory practices. It is important to ask the questions: Where do stigmatising narratives originate from? Who benefits from the continued stigmatisation of queer people? What is it about specific queer identities that dominant cultures strive to repress? As some queer identities are being recognised and gaining visibility, who is left behind?
Fortunately, there has been an increase in the number of emerging psychologists who seek to get trained in queer affirmative therapy practices. Despite this interest, however, it is relevant to question how effective therapy can be when it takes the individual out of their context. While advocating for LGBTQIA+ mental health is important, it is meaningless to separate mental health from the larger social structures, norms, and narratives that contribute to their exclusions and othering experiences. We can truly make positive progress in queer mental health by holding these institutions accountable, advocating for social justice, and recognising those queer people who are invisibilised further amongst the larger queer population due to holding multiple marginalised identities.










